PROMETHEUS (
Dir. Ridley Scott)
Ridley Scott said from the start that you shouldn't talk about
Prometheus in relation to
Alien. Yes, it's a prequel, and yes, it's 'in the same universe' or 'in the same timeline', but it most certainly isn't set on the same planet, and don't expect any xenomorphs. Sincerely, Ridley Scott. ps. I lied. On both counts.
Prometheus was an enjoyable watch and I loved it as a film, but as a long-time fan of
Alien I couldn't help noticing how, essentially, it was a remake - or an update. Same director, same idea. Sure, some plotlines were different, but it had the same elements of horror and gore that with
Alien birthed a whole new subgenre of sci-fi.
Prometheus (similarly) is not
shocking but rather
horrifying - and kinda disgusting in parts. It pushes this sci-fi realism to its edges, much like
Alien did. And Noomi Rapace, fantastic in the main role as Dr. Elizabeth Shaw, is pretty much 2012's answer to Sigourney Weaver's Ellen Ripley. She's tense, she's edgy, and yet still kinda sexy. There are throwbacks to
Alien all through
Prometheus, from the crew smoking and drinking on the ship, to Rapace's end monologue voiceover (and her final scene smacks of ol' Sigourney's revealing escape pod scene, too). I'm not saying it's a bad thing, I'm just saying Scott isn't trying to be subtle.
Visually, the film was amazing - almost faultless. And the CGI is accompanied by an oddly orchestral score, which, when it gets a chance, soars over the visuals but luckily for the film's tone it doesn't do this
too often. In terms of acting, performances are quite split down the middle; those that are exceptional and those that are quite commonplace. What makes the difference is the opportunities a certain character brings: Michael Fassbender excels as the android David, going above and beyond what Ian Holm did in 1979. He almost stole the show if it weren't for all Noomi Rapace's airtime. Behind them, Charlize Theron plays a heartless bitch (again) and Guy Pearce plays old man Weyland as convincingly as a young man can.
So, ultimately, the question to ask is 'which is better:
Prometheus or
Alien?', but I don't know the answer. They're both appropriate for their time - but there was something intangible, so subtle, about
Alien's casual tone that is lost in today's sci-fi blockbuster. Perhaps it just had a little too much Hollywood sheen to it.
★★★★☆